Page 1 of 3

FMF Gnarly vs. Stock pipe comparison

Posted: October 20th, 2008, 6:28 pm
by TYSTYX
In case anyone wants to know the difference between the two.

I have never had anything but FMF Gnarlys on my bike, so after my pipe cracked a few weeks ago I found a nice stock pipe and slapped it on. I ride desert consisting of dunes, sandy river washes, sandy hills, fast and slow trails, etc. At first the stock pipe felt really weird compared to what I was used to. The bottom hit was less than the Gnarly was, but not really enough to bother me, even on the slow technical trails. The first time I ripped up a tall sand hill also felt strange. Again the torque felt less, but the bike was able to rev out more with the stock pipe, and with a 500 the lessened torque didnt really make a difference in the bike's climbing ability. On this one hill I usually start close to the bottom and upshift as Im going up the hill. With the Gnarly I would always end up in 4th gear about 3/4's the way up, but with the stock pipe I would hit 3rd gear about half way up and just leave it......and it seemed to carry the same speed as 4th gear on the Gnarly. After about an hour of hard riding I really started to like the feel of the stock pipe because the ability to rev out more was perfect for me plus the bike felt much faster since I could spread the gears out a little more. I havnt had a chance to ride it in the dunes yet, but Im 100% sure Im going to love it.

Posted: October 20th, 2008, 6:36 pm
by MICK
That's why I'm a Pro Circuit fan. Because the stocker feels to me like your FMF does to the stocker. I don't mind the softer bottem end. I like that I can use the shit out of every gear. The FMF's have a place in this community for sure. But the power delivery they produce just rubs me wrong. The way I ride I just feel the FMF Gnarly ruins the CR/KX500 powerbands. Now the old Fatty's they made...that was a whole different story.

Posted: October 20th, 2008, 6:47 pm
by TYSTYX
MICK wrote: The way I ride I just feel the FMF Gnarly ruins the CR/KX500 powerbands.
After riding the stock pipe, I have to agree !! For Christmas I'll buy my bike a Pro Circuit pipe. :D

Posted: October 20th, 2008, 7:25 pm
by teemtrubble
Yep that's what I keep saying....

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 2:59 pm
by Balaclava
cool...one day i'm gunna get that teemtrubble pro circuit works system. one day very soon. :lol:

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 5:55 pm
by 100hp honda
PC really shines when its mated with topend port job :wink: . stock pipe also works good. only problem i had with both pipes is they soften the bottom end too much for me

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 6:02 pm
by britincali
Ive experienced the complete opposite, the PC sucked nuts for top end :?

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 6:42 pm
by pstoffers
britincali wrote:Ive experienced the complete opposite, the PC sucked nuts for top end :?
X998987654328887999987898888765544467888 :applaud:

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 6:57 pm
by AlisoBob
britincali wrote:Ive experienced the complete opposite, the PC sucked nuts for top end :?
Lean it out more......

Image

Posted: November 8th, 2008, 7:21 pm
by britincali
No spooge, chocolate brown plug, brown grey inside the silencer, squeezin the shit out of it......




I aint leaning it out any :wink:

Posted: November 10th, 2008, 2:31 pm
by MICK
britincali wrote:Ive experienced the complete opposite, the PC sucked nuts for top end :?
What pipe do you know of has more top end than a PC? It's not the stocker or FMF that's for damn sure.

Posted: November 10th, 2008, 2:57 pm
by britincali
Noleen.

Posted: November 10th, 2008, 5:00 pm
by pstoffers
MICK wrote:
britincali wrote:Ive experienced the complete opposite, the PC sucked nuts for top end :?
What pipe do you know of has more top end than a PC? It's not the stocker or FMF that's for damn sure.


:roll:

Posted: November 11th, 2008, 5:52 am
by MICK
pstoffers wrote:
MICK wrote:What pipe do you know of has more top end than a PC? It's not the stocker or FMF that's for damn sure.

:roll:
You've got to be kidding...

Posted: November 11th, 2008, 8:13 am
by pstoffers
MICK wrote:
pstoffers wrote:
MICK wrote:What pipe do you know of has more top end than a PC? It's not the stocker or FMF that's for damn sure.

:roll:
You've got to be kidding...


NOPE I'm not.....

Posted: November 11th, 2008, 12:36 pm
by ISBB
i rode my bike with a PC one weekend sold it shortly after.. im puttin the gnarly back on and gonna ride the piss outta it :D

Posted: November 11th, 2008, 12:49 pm
by dannygraves
FMF Fatty, or old regular gold series all the way. power characteristics like a stock pipe with a little more all over. :twisted:
I've got one of each and the gnarly is leaving with the next bike I sell. :wink:

Posted: October 19th, 2009, 7:38 am
by Darrell262
My 500 came with a pc pipe. Its still on it. I don't know what stock was like.

my ktm 300 stocker was ok. I put on a fmf fatty and I seen the light

FMF Fatty on my 300 is hands down better then the stocker. Revs higher then stock, It holds power band in 3rd gear all the way to the top of a hill I climb alot (stocker wouldnt, I had to gear down to 2nd) I had to rejet the the bike from a 162main to a 165 main after putting the fatty on cause it was too lean for my liking, and I noticed the bike pulled better on the top end after the fatter jet anyhow)

I tryed a FMF Gnarly on a af cr 500 (ice racing) and I also tryed a ktm 200 with a gnarly as well I didn't like the ktm 200. I felt like it lost way too much top end. Pretty much killed it)

and the gnarly on the 500 didn't work out so well just because your pinning it all the time racing. top end wasn't as good.

Posted: October 19th, 2009, 10:27 am
by Roostius_Maximus
a little field shootout yesterday against bro, he was almost able to keep up :lol:
I'm 40lbs on bro, he's piped gnarly and running a pj, i had the pwk+fatty
i could pull him from dead stop + way up top right thru 5th on a soft field, and held it out for almost 1/2 a mile. was 14C out and i was light on the pilot, would detonate when letting off slow. both of us added about an inch of blue to the pipes but the only part failure was the loss of a millville that got cut on a rock.

Posted: November 9th, 2009, 8:44 am
by LOVEMYCR500
has anyone tried the new CPI CR500 sand pipe yet? They claim 9 hp over stock pipe on a stock port motor. they produce and sell alot of banshee and snowmobile pipes and I know the banshee pipe is very popular.

Posted: November 9th, 2009, 9:19 am
by dannygraves
a friend of mine had CPI pipes on his banshee and used to smoke all the other (much more built $$$) banshees. his was mildly ported, stock heads, 36mm PJs and cpi pipes and he was smoking stroker motors with powervalve jugs and toomley pipes.
he claimed it was those cpi pipes :wink:

Posted: November 9th, 2009, 4:18 pm
by LOVEMYCR500
I'm not made of money but for $299.00 unplated I might have to try one. They are a beast of a pipe from seeing the picture on their website.

Posted: November 11th, 2009, 10:08 am
by 100hp honda
stock motor is lame and probly wont work well with the sand pipe, granted it will work but not to full potential. defiantly wont ever see 9hp on a stock motor. cpi said the test bike was ported etc.. probly all topend porting im assuming.

Posted: November 12th, 2009, 8:32 am
by LOVEMYCR500
ha interesting, I e-mailed them and asked if the 9 hp was actually factual since that's a huge increase just slapping a pipe on and if the porting was stock. They told me that the bike was completely stock so here we go I guess.

I will probably do some clean up porting on mine but that's it. I asked them what the power spread of this pipe is and never responded. I'm sure it's all top end. CPI guys are riding the dunes in Idaho and Utah and the sand is soft and the hills are steep and long, perfect for this kind of pipe.

Posted: November 12th, 2009, 6:29 pm
by 100hp honda
must of been the secretary lady that responded to your email :lol: . i would call them next time. not saying youll get 100% facts on the phone either but it should be more accurate than email. i wouldnt bother with clean up porting... theres nothing to clean up, its a waste of time, and does nothing for making power...... anyone that tells you other wise is a liar. if you dont know the proper port timings to make it run strong then i would send it to someone that knows. packard and jerry hall make them run good but theres a couple more shops that can do a good job. go BIG or go home :headbang: